IB History Students
What do you think of this source?
posted by Mr. Carlisle at 1:10 PM
Tuesday, September 15, 2009
About Me
- Name: Mr. Carlisle
- Location: Portland, Oregon, United States
I'm a native South Carolinian and I attained my undergraduate and graduate degrees from the University of South Carolina. I taught fourth grade for two years in the Mississippi Delta and two years at an alternative high school in Western North Carolina. I have been at Tigard High School since the fall of 2003, where I teach U.S. History and Psychology.
Previous Posts
- Adv. US History
- IB History Students--PARTICIPATION POINTS OPPORTUNITY
- September 14
- Hope everyone has a great weekend. Looking forward...
- Adv. US History
- SC Congressman Calls the President a Liar
- September 10
- Welcome to the 2009-10 School Year!
- Behold President Obama's speech to America's youth...
- Resources to aid in the learning of history
24 Comments:
I think it would be a good source except the plane kind of looks photoshopped in...
4:03 PM
The shadows don't look quite right...
4:42 PM
That is an awesome picture. It gives me chills haha.
4:42 PM
i havent seen that image before. now i have, and i find it sorta funny
6:49 PM
1. You can see the pixels around the date on the bottom corner. That means it was probably edited on Paint. At least that bit was.
2. The coloring/shading of the airplane is brighter. The photo resolution on the nose of the plane is more defined than the rest of the photo.
Fake photograph. But very cool, nonetheless.
7:21 PM
Would someone really stop to take a picture on the top of a building while a plane is coming right at it??? I know I wouldn't.
7:38 PM
I think i've seen the same photo on the front of the National Enquirer where you could see Bigfoot in the cockpit.
8:11 PM
Haha its Austin. Anybody else hear about what Obama said about Kanye West? Very very funny. Its probably on youtube by now so look it up.
8:36 PM
How did they get this picture developed if the plane is coming right at him?????
8:55 PM
Shouldn't the plane be casting a shadow on the building under it? Also, I agree with Rimma about the date and the coloring.
9:01 PM
This picture is definately photoshopped or whatever it is that the person does with their free time. Just take a moment to consider the following: How is it possible that a picture taken on the roof moments before the hit, was able to be developed? The guy that took it wouldn't be able to develop it, nor could the guy getting his picture taken ;and the chances of the camera surviving and being found on top of that are slim to none.
9:23 PM
I do not think it is a primary source photo. Why is the plane not blury like the rest of the city? And I agree with some other fellow peers, why would you be taking a picture while a plane is coming towards it? I totally think it it photoshop.
9:45 PM
why and how did the man stand up there without being scared of the plane thats about to crash? He actually had the time to stand there and take a photograph of the plane before it crash landed. Thats amazing.
9:47 PM
How do you take someones picture and not notice that there is a plane flying right at you?
10:15 PM
Even though it is photoshopped thats still a pretty intense picture.
10:17 PM
I agree with everything Mary says. There's no chance this picture is legit. photoshopped. good work to the guy who created this though. he must have a lot of free time on his hands.
10:33 PM
How would they get the camera down?
11:22 AM
wow. the photographer is PRO and must be some sort of being with wings. C(X anyway, the photo was obviously photoshopped, as described by Rimma. I think it was a nice try though. LOL
8:22 PM
i think it looks cool, butn i dont see the shadow that dont look right. i think its fake cuz at the bottom right it says 9am, and i think it happened around 7 or 8
7:21 AM
o and how would the camera survive
7:23 AM
I wouln't trust it because there is no way that the camera survived. It is a cool pic though
2:55 PM
I would assume that this picture is photoshopped, since I know I would not stop and take a picture of a plane comming right at me?
8:40 PM
This was very photoshopped.
8:41 AM
I took the Pic
9:27 PM
Post a Comment
<< Home